Innovation and Value
What is innovation?
The week 1 seminar asked the room, laptops closed, and collected these answers:
- Solving someone’s problems or trying to improve their situation
- Creating value for a client or customer
- Improving something that exists with a different mindset
- Creating a new solution to a problem that changes how things are done
- Creating meaningful items that the customer wants to pay for
- Improving upon an existing solution
The common thread — and the course’s one-line definition — is innovation = creating value for someone.
Value is defined by the customer, not the maker
“Quality in a product or service is not what the supplier puts in. It is what the customer gets out and is willing to pay for. A product is not quality because it is hard to make and costs a lot of money, as manufacturers typically believe. This is incompetence. Customers pay only for what is of use to them and gives them value. Nothing else constitutes quality.”
— Peter Drucker
This is the assumption the whole course rests on. Effort, cleverness and cost do not create value; only what the customer gets out does. It’s also why the process starts with customer-discovery rather than with building.
Why we need an innovation process
Because products and businesses fail, and mostly for reasons that have nothing to do with the code:
| Failure reason | Percentage |
|---|---|
| Cash flow | 38% |
| No market fit | 35% |
| Competition | 20% |
| Business model | 19% |
| Regulatory challenges | 18% |
| Pricing issues | 15% |
| Team | 14% |
| Timing | 10% |
(The percentages exceed 100% because failures usually have several causes.) The single most addressable item on that list for a student team is no market fit — 35% of failures come from building something nobody wanted.
The solution the course proposes: focus on the customer, and answer three questions in order.
- What are their problems?
- Do we have a solution? Can we make one?
- Will they pay for our solution?
From development to innovation
Four shifts distinguish an innovation process from ordinary product development:
| From | To | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | A client | A market segment (customers) |
| 2 | A system | A value proposition |
| 3 | Development | Experimentation |
| 4 | A requirements specification | A Minimum Viable Product |
Each shift has its own machinery later in the course: market segments and value propositions in business-model-canvas and value-proposition-canvas, experimentation in experimentation, and the MVP in minimum-viable-products.
Divergent thinking for creative design
When generating ideas rather than evaluating them:
- Don’t challenge or criticise.
- Quantity, not quality.
- Do not analyse or organise — but do record and draw.
- Then identify significant themes, and refine.
The separation matters: the generating phase and the judging phase are different activities, and mixing them kills the first one.
Key takeaways
- Innovation = creating value for someone.
- Failure is often because we do not understand our market.
- Success is more likely if we get out of the building.
- An innovation process means generating and testing ideas early, so we fail early.
- Failure is an opportunity to learn.